AbbySparwasser
For more than 50 years, “Saturday Night Live” (“SNL”) has aired on NBC every Saturday at 10:30 CT. But for its first three seasons, the iconic show was known as the “Not Ready for Prime Time Players,” according to NBC.
This name was in reference to the obscure actors they cast for the first few seasons. At the time, they could have hired more prominent people to act in the show, but they continued this tradition of picking the underdog.
According to Backstage.com, a website to find auditions, it isn’t new news that “SNL” talent scouts go to standup shows to find new talent in New York City. According to the same website, original “SNL” cast member Laraine Newman said that director Lorne Michaels had come to the Groundlings, a standup improv group, to watch their show. There, Newman was cast as part of the first season.
For its 52nd season, new stars on the show have paved their way into the comedy sphere prior to their first appearance on “SNL.” Grace Reiter, a new actor on “SNL,” got her start on TikTok, gaining over 4.1 million followers doing comedy through the app alone. As well as this, she joined the sketch group “American High Shorts” in late 2022. The group posted comedy shorts filmed in a high school on TikTok, YouTube, Instagram and other social media platforms.
Though Reiter may have had a successful career prior to debuting on “SNL,” she certainly isn’t the only “SNL” star who got their start on social media. Jeremy Culhane, an “SNL” actor who first appeared in season 51, became famous for his Tucker Carlson impression in numerous comedy sketches on the show. However, he initially appeared on the online sketch comedy group “Dropout” in 2023, according to IMDB.
Today, both of these actors have prominent roles on “SNL,” leading the way for a new social media-to-“SNL” pipeline that has become more common.

Paige Wollensack, who is currently a project manager at a commercial agency, interned at “SNL” in 2014-2015 in its 40th season.
“I wasn’t involved in [casting] directly, but I’ve read and heard and listened to every single person’s story about how they got casted,” Wollensack said. “[The casting process has] been primarily going to stand-up sets and clubs and going to other improv shows.”
Even though social media presence may play a role in casting, Wollensack added that “SNL” hasn’t changed its casting process dramatically. “The show is very traditional,” Wollensack said. “Of course they’re still going to go through their, you know, [going to] those stand-up clubs and the improv shows.”
Casting isn’t the only aspect of “SNL” that social media is affecting. According to history.com, the Writers Guild of America (WGA) went on strike from late 2007 to early 2008 after a disagreement with the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers (AMPTP). On Nov. 5, 2007, writers staged a walkout, halting the production of television across the country.
“The writer’s strike… obviously was a huge turning point for everything getting online, and that’s why like so many other sketches just like were dumped online in 2009,” Wollensack said. Today, the “SNL” YouTube channel features 10,000 videos and 17.4 million followers, illustrating its popularity on the platform.
“At least you have all those sketches that go that don’t make it from dress to air. You get to see those online, which is really fun,” Wollensack said.
Nate Johnson, an actor, writer and director in the film industry, shared his perspective on casting from a broader view of the television industry. “You have a lot more remote auditions,” Johnson said.
Even though “SNL” casting may be affected by social media, it hasn’t been altered entirely. “There were always grumblings that people with larger social media followings tended to get more acting jobs,” Johnson said. “I don’t know how much truth was actually in that, because a lot of people with social media followings aren’t great actors.”
With new stars that appeal to younger audiences, “SNL” has a newer, stronger presence with generations such as Gen Z. Junior Kaitlyn Cooper has been a fan of “SNL” for multiple seasons now. “I try to watch SNL every Saturday during the season, but that isn’t always possible, so if I miss a night, I will watch the clips of it online somewhere usually the next morning,” Cooper said.
During their initial appearances on “SNL,” Cooper recognized a few of the newer stars. She knew of Reiter due to her online presence before Reiter appeared on the show. “I watched [Reiter] there [on ‘American High Shorts’], but also in her rendition of the Hunger Games ‘The Hunger Games but Better,’” Cooper said.
As Cooper watches “SNL” on air, she has noticed its attempts to keep up with its new audiences. “By having an online presence, casting known people within the generation and making pop culture references, they are able to stay relevant to multiple generations.,” Cooper said.
With social media, “SNL” actors like Reiter and Culhane could get their start by dipping their toes in the comedy world. And without their social media platforms or the confidence gained by it, they may not have been cast on “SNL.”
Even though “SNL” is no longer called the “Not Ready for Prime Time Players,” the show still hires obscure comedians regularly, whether they got their start on social media or not.






Leave a Reply